My Spaniel enjoys these treats, he appears to like the crunch and The point that It's not 1 Chunk and long gone. The resealable packet retains them fresh and crunchy. These are definitely a quality treat, well manufactured with NO artificial ingredients and so they odor the same as peanut https://goodboycrunchiespeanutbut93680.blogsuperapp.com/32266018/the-ultimate-guide-to-goodboy-chicken-carrot-stick-320g